I'm pleased to see the designer took my comments in the way they were intended, rather than the way people seem to have twisted them in to.
Someone please explain something to me.
Someone releases a layout which shouldn't really see the light of day.
Do you
A) Insult their intelligence, tell them it's great, and get wave after wave of layouts from people who with a bit of a nudge could produce some good work, or

Tell them it needs to be improved. I may be a bit blunt in my approach but I genuinely don't think I come across as offensive.
f*** me it's no wonder theres so many people in this country who can't read or do maths when they come out of school, if people aren't interested in making people work a bit harder to better themselves. If you let people get slack, you get slack results.
So thanks to the designer for knuckling down and improving it. I'd gladly give you some advice / lessons if need be.
Oh, and to those who come back and say I'm being a c*** - the person I was actually talking to doesn't seem to be complaining.